About Advertise
Culture, Leisure, Reality
Boswell Circus

Chief of a Strange Tribe

by Samora Chapman / 10.08.2012

The circus has been visiting Durban for many years. I’ve always been intrigued when they arrive in town… the band of strangers dragging their ramshackle life, their ‘wild’ animals, tents and trailers in tow. There is something so surreal about seeing two giant elephants parking under a palm tree on the side of the road, in the midst of the concrete jungle every morning. It just doesn’t seem right.

Every year the humans flock in droves to salivate over the candy-floss and animal entertainment. But this year something changed. The opposition arrived with picket signs. To save the shackled beasts from the circus freaks.

At the forefront of the protester was a tall man with golden-grey hair like a hyena’s main. He was striding up and down the line of protestors with gleaming eyes, giving charismatic speeches to the media. Steve Smit of Animal Rights Africa is no stranger to this fight. “I’ve been battling Boswell for 27 years. I’m gonna go over there right now and make him nervous,” he says with vicious energy.

I walked up and down the frontline listening to opinions: “You see how the elephants are swaying?” Explained the timid Jaryd Sage. “That’s a sign that they are in distress. Those are two unhappy elephants.” Jaryd is responsible for organising the weekly pickets outside Boswell’s. “The aim is to raise public awareness, generate support and eventually challenge the laws that protect Boswell,” he tells me.

I stalk off to talk to Brian Boswell as he stands on the other side of the fence… swaying too, like an animal in distress. But I’m intercepted and turned away: “Come back another time,” says his daughter Georgina Boswell. “Things are very stressful right now.”

It takes almost two weeks of phone calls and emails to acquire an interview with old man Boswell. Eventually I find myself following the tired old Ringmaster with his bad limp into a hidden fold of his circus tent. I’m under strict orders: no discussing the animal rights protests, no pictures and no animal abuse accusations.

I try to make small talk: “I’m sorry to hear about your hip replacement Mr Boswell. How did it go? My mother’s had two knee replacements, so I know it’s a very painful experience.”

Boswell eases into an old plastic chair and waves his hand dismissing the question. “I’ve already had three hip replacements. I’ve got no time to rest. I’ve got things to do. People to see. I make four or five overseas trips a year to see circuses and attend conferences. I’ve been to China, Hungary, Germany, Peru, Paris, Rome, Italy…” the list goes on.

I’m in the Ringmaster’s domain now. The tired body is a guise. His mind is a wild pony. “I’m pretty astonished,” I say, “I thought the circus was a thing of a past. How many circuses are there in South Africa… and do they all have animals?”

“There are more circuses now than there have ever been,” he says. “There are five in South Africa. They all have animals. Circuses without animals always close.”

“What about Cirque du Soleil? Isn’t it one of the most successful circuses in history?” I probe.

“I actually have a letter from Cirque du Soleil stating that they are not opposed to circus animals. Yes, they run an incredible show… but it’s not my cup of tea. Cirque du Soleil is a factory. They produce a new circus every year. I saw them in Paris… I met them. I know them.”

Old Man Boswell is a fifth generation Ringmaster. The circus and its history flows through his veins. These are Carny folk. It’s etched on his leathery red face. Nomads. He’s travelled many miles with his band of performers and animals. Dragging tents, hounds, children, beasts, gymnasts and daredevils from town to town. Setting up camp on vacant thorny field… no place to call home. Always under the big starry sky.

“We travel 12 months of the year. We’ve closed three times in 30 years. We travel South Africa, Botswana, Zimbabwe, Mozambique… but it always gets harder. It gets harder to cross borders and harder to acquire animals. There are many permits you need, which there never was before.”

Boswell is drowned out by a baby and a pack of poodles howling in unison from the caravan across the way. “It’s a nomadic way of life,” he says like a chief of a strange tribe. An old lady in uniform comes and offers us drinks. “Cream Soda,” says Boswell. I go for water. He sips the green juice and delves into the annals of time.

“My ancestors can be traced back to 1752 and the birth of the modern circus. The first actual Boswell’s Circus was formed in 1848 in England. In 1911 my grandfather and his four sons came to South Africa and started Boswell’s here. But in the 60s the circus was sold to African Theatres, which then joined with Wilkies to form The Boswell Wilkies Circus.”

When his father’s circus was sold off Boswell was a youth in his 20s, and all he’d ever known was the circus life. Disillusioned by the loss of the family circus, young Boswell headed for England. He literally ran away from his circus to join another. The renowned Chipperfields Circus.
“I was working the lions, tigers, bears,” he explains like he’s talking about the cool breeze. “I soon became Ringmaster. My father had taught me everything about the circus.”

A few years later Boswell toured South Africa with the Chipperfields Circus. He ended up marrying one of the “Chipperfields girls” as he puts it, and stayed in SA to resurrect his great grandfather’s beloved Boswell’s Circus.

“I started Brian’s Circus in 1982… since my father had sold off to African Theatres and we’d lost our name to Wilkie. Wilkie died in ‘98 and their show closed in 2001, which is when we finally got our name back.”

Has the circus changed over time?

“No, the circus has always been quite similar. Always lions, Asian elephants, zebras, monkeys, baboons, dogs. It’s a ‘traditional circus’. Human performances are always the same. Everything’s been done.”

Have you ever considered a circus without animals?

“When people come to the circus, they expect to see animals. We are here to entertain the public and you have to give people what they want. We are inspected by our audience and by animal welfare societies. They can come whenever they want.”

Boswell checks his old gold watch and announces that it’s time for the show. Our interview ends abruptly and I try sneak in a last question on our way to the main tent: “One last question Mr Boswell… do you ever get kids arriving at your gate. Like kids who’ve run away to join the circus?”

“Oh yes of course.” He says. “You see Jimmy over there? Him and his four brothers all joined the circus that way. And Richie too. He’s been fired 13 times and he just keeps coming back. Hey Richie! How many times you been fired?”

The rough cat manning the roundabout just shrugs and smiles.

“The circus becomes your family. My daughter Georgina is slowly taking over. She’ll be working the lions today.”

As we enter the arena a scary looking clown shows me to my seat and tells me that no photographs are allowed during the show… but that it’s okay if I take photographs. “Shit, I never brought my camera,” I say frustrated, looking around for Mr Boswell in an attempt to validate the clown’s orders. I’m left wondering if it’s a trick. Why had the clown delivered the message? Luckily I’ve got a kak two megapixel camera on my Blackboerie. It’ll have to do.

Dance Money - Clown Act

The show finally commences with an announcement by a man in a starry cape: “Welcome to Boswell’s International Circus! First up we have the amazing Georgina Boswell and the lionesses!” He says in a horrible radio voice. He forces a pained mannequin grin.

Dance Monkey - Opening Image

Georgina chases the beautiful lions around with a whip. They pad around as fluid as water. Subservient, but proud. Awesome up close. Next up is trapeze followed by Mongolian looking cats juggling, a soulless skit by the sad clowns, horses trotting in circles, feisty pigs doing tricks and some much needed comic relief from the poodles, which drove the crowd wild.

Dance Monkey - Acrobats

The episode ends with Georgina dancing with an incredible galloping wild horse. Its coat was like that of an Nguni cow, and its eyes shone and flashed. The horse galloped explosively around the ring as Georgina snapped her whip, guiding the animal this way and that. There was something in the horse’s eyes that spoke to me… like it had transcended its captivity. It was caged, but its spirit was still wild. It was the most beautiful horse I have ever seen.

Dance Monkey - Horse

I left at the interval. I couldn’t face the elephant show.

The people of Boswells did not come across as cruel or mean-hearted as many of the ‘progressive’ people across the road might think. I have my reservations about the animal show. But there are far greater evils than Boswell’s Circus. Evils that have been totally normalised in modern society.

For instance, why did a hundred people come out to protest against a small independent circus when Mcdonalds is spreading around the country like an epidemic? What about the hunting industry? What about the mass industrialised slaughter and cruelty inherent in the meat and poultry business? What is the difference between eating KFC, dog or dolphin? Why do thousands of brilliantly trendy socialites attend the Durban July without a flinch… but when a little family run circus comes to town everyone gets outraged?

Don’t get me wrong; I think the protests are necessary. They will help build awareness… but Boswell is operating fully within the law. For anything to change, the animal rights groups must lobby their issue with government and challenge the laws pertaining to animals in entertainment.

Maybe the next generation of Boswells will see that the circus can succeed without exotic animals, as Cirque de Soleil has proved. But for me, the circus only sheds light on a much deeper issue… we are so far removed from nature that it has become almost impossible to tell right from wrong.

Two hundred years ago Saartjie Baartman was put in a cage and exported to Europe as the star of a freak show. She was dubbed the ‘Hottentot Venus’. Fifty years ago the great Madiba was put in a cage for 27 years; a freedom fighter charged with treason. Today, women are put in cages and stoned to death for falling in love with the wrong man.

Lets hope one day humans will start treating each other like humans… then maybe the animals will get a better deal.

*All images © Samora Chapman.

12   0
RESPONSES (17)
  1. kvetch says:

    do you guys have a sub-editor? is he/she asleep today?

    e.g. “a hyena’s main”?

    Thumb up0   Thumb down 0

  2. Tsk says:

    Fok, kvetch, you beat me to it. I think they’re all at Oppikoppi sucking brandy outta some dusty bosbok’s naval. You know, like the orange.

    Thumb up0   Thumb down 0

  3. Nick says:

    I remember going to The Boswell-Wilkie Circus in Pietermaritzburg as a laaitie. I remember that the inclusion of animals in the circus and the possibility that they were being treated poorly was an issue that my parents felt uneasy about. We went to see the show in spite of that. I think arguing against the inclusion of animals in the circus is an issue; but one that should be raised in the context of how we treat animals in general.

    Thumb up0   Thumb down 0

  4. IThink says:

    “Lets hope one day humans will start treating each other like humans… then maybe the animals will get a better deal.”

    True that

    Thumb up0   Thumb down 0

  5. Google+ says:

    “What is the difference between eating KFC, dog or dolphin?”
    Yeah, totally, fuck! Ban meat! We’re savages, monsters, take away the braai! You’ve totally opened the world’s eyes to the atrociousness we have a part in.

    Thumb up0   Thumb down 0

  6. Frank says:

    To think it started out so nicely, and then it turned into a vegetarian’s ramble.

    Thumb up0   Thumb down 0

  7. SIPHO says:

    I wouldn’t have read this if I knew it wasn’t really about Boswell. You just sneaked in the last part didn’t you.

    Thumb up0   Thumb down 0

  8. reality says:

    Where on earth do people. (humans?) get the idea that life in the wild is some idealistic paradise. You’re one of two things, prey species or predator – prey species spend their life foraging for food and avoiding, for as long as possible, being food . By being food inevitably means being slowly eaten alive by a pack of predators, there ain’t no thing as sedentary old age in the wild . The predator consumes until such a time it is unable to and then, ends up being torn to shreds by either their own, or another species pack. – h’mm, no stress there at all. As a human, go try and scratch a living from the soil, on your own, without recourse to supermarket or specialist delicatessen, and see how long you survive. Yes, there are cases of animal abuse in circuses, there are also many cases of child abuse – the solution, ban childbirth? No, we single out the abusers.

    Thumb up0   Thumb down 0

  9. Jaryd says:

    @reality I think you’re missing the whole point. The fact that these wild animals are being kept in a cage and forced to travel around the country and ignore just about any and every natural instinct that they have is animal abuse enough. While beating and whipping animals in circuses is a common training method, this doesn’t need to take place to constitute animal abuse. If someone kept their dog in a cage for 19 hours a day I’m thinking most people would take issue – yet those same people are happy enough to make excuses for the circus so that they can attend guilt-free? People should consider the consequences of their actions instead of brushing them off because them or their loved one’s aren’t being directly affected.

    Thumb up0   Thumb down 0

  10. Jaryd says:

    If you want to find out more info you can visit this FB page and look at the notes, photos and videos: http://www.facebook.com/BoycottBrianBoswellsAnimalCircus

    I urge you to check out this info to make an INFORMED decision about visiting the circus.

    Thumb up0   Thumb down 0

  11. Not Impressed says:

    That circus is sooooo lame. I felt worse for the washout circus folk than for the animals..

    Thumb up0   Thumb down 0

  12. Juliano says:

    Here is a link to my documentary on Boswell circus

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W5zQ6S5sw_Y

    Thumb up0   Thumb down 0

  13. Anonymous says:

    you beat me to it. “soils compassion” watch the space!

    Thumb up0   Thumb down 0

  14. Michael Glover says:

    @Frank

    Eating meat = environmentally unsustainable, speciesist, extreme water and protein wastage, acute cruelty, unhealthy, expensive and inhumane.

    Einstein, Pythagoras, Newton, Tesla, Thomas Edison, Thom Yorke (is), J.M Coetzee (is) Tolstoy were all vegetarians. I suppose you (Frank a nobody, a bloviating ignoramus) are more visionary than them.

    It’s not a ramble, you halfwit. And don’t reply until you have a clue what you’re talking about.
    The worst thing about morons is that they’re so often too moronic to know that they’re morons.

    Nice work Samora. You’ve a good heart.

    Thumb up0   Thumb down 0

  15. Anonymous says:

    I went to the circus recently. One question? Why would they reward them with treats if they can just lift up a wip and scare them into doing the tricks? Think people! If there was any evidence of cruelty, you would see it in the way that the animals react to the people handeling them! Are you living their lives? Are you there every second of every day to see everything that they do? Walk a mile in someone elses shoes first I always say!

    Thumb up0   Thumb down 0

  16. Anonymous says:

    Guys this is not a “should we eat meat” discussion. The circus uses a reward system as training method. AKA POSITIVE REINFORCEMENT!!!!!! IF YOU BEAT AN ANIMAL IT WILL NOT WORK FOR YOU! They are kind soft people who are amazing animal trainers! would you ban the use of animals in movies? same thing, just the circus does it all in front of your eyes without beating their animals. Their whips are mere extensions of their arms, they communicate with animals larger than them, its a tool not a torture device! Stop being silly, im sure, if you have real concerns, you could go to them and ask to sit in on a practice. You might even learn something.

    Thumb up0   Thumb down 0

LEAVE A REPLY

Loading...